A couple weeks ago, Stephanie (now my wife) bought me an iPhone for my birthday. I thought I would let you know my take on it after having used it for a little while...
- First, let me start by saying that this is hands down the best phone I have ever used, period. Just like every new technology, it has its bugs, but the bottom line is this: there has never been a "smartphone" that comes as close to actually being smart as the iPhone.
- Second, I don't own a Mac, so don't read this review thinking that I am a crazy Mac evangelist (I do have quite a few of Apple's cool products, but no Mac).
As a phone...
Yeah, it has tons of cools widgets, but the first question you should ask is, "How is it as a phone?" It's superb. Calls are clear, contacts are easy to find, and in-call controls show up when you need them, and go away when you don't. When you are in a call, 6 buttons appear on the screen for useful things like Speaker, Mute, Hold, etc. When the call ends, those buttons go away. Add Call is another nice feature which allows you to call another person and start a 3 way call. The speaker is a bit too quiet for me, making a Speakerphone call hard to pull off say in a moving car.
As an iPod...
Coverflow is a cool way of rifling through your albums to find the song you want to play. I would guess the next gen iPods will have to incorporate a touch screen in order to utilize this feature. The inlcuded headset is nice, and the phone will mute and unmute the music gracefully before and after a call comes in. It would be nice if the iPhone would do crossfade playback, but as of now it doesn't. Seems like something Apple could easily fix with a firmware update.
Surfing...
While much better than any other phone I have surfed on, Safari is easily the weakest link the iPhone has. It crashes unexpectedly, the bookmarks are hard to get used to, and the browser does not support Flash, which renders a lot of today's webpages less functional than they could be. That being said, once you get used to it, it is very handy to be able to access the web from anywhere at any time. The iPhone data plan (a requirement to activate the phone) is a cheap $20 a month for unlimited access, and the iPhone senses when you are in range of a WiFi hotspot and automatically uses it if it can, speeding up the process. AT&T's EDGE data network is slow, but think of it as a lifeline for when you are not range of a hotspot.
Other cool tools...
Maps is great. I have used it a lot. It uses Google maps as its data source, and the look and feel is very similar. Driving directions are easy to page through, or if you want to go off the beaten path, just slide the map around, zoom in, zoom out. Traffic info is available for many major cities. I knew there was going to be a traffic jam in downtown Jacksonville before I got there last week.
The camera is good for a phone based camera, and the multitouch interface really shines when zooming and cropping photos.
Text (SMS) messaging is nice, with entire conversations saved as long as you want them, but the inability to text (MMS) photos to another person is mysterious. Instead, the iPhone opens an email window and attaches the photo into an email. Not helpful if the person you want to send the pic to is not online at the time.
Weather is handy, but it would be nice to be able to see radar or a more detailed forecast. The weather tool gives you the high and low temps for the next six days, but only gives a cryptic cartoon-like depiction of the actual weather conditions for the day. I wish I could tap to get more detail.
YouTube is cool, and once their entire catalog is transcoded to the iPhone supported format, I can imagine that a person might watch a lot less TV.